This will come as a surprise to no one, I'm sure. Gauge issues, big time. (Wait--what did you think I was talking about?) A couple of weekends ago I started some new socks and knit two swatches* and all three ran into the sucking quicksand of my eternal inability...well, I don't even know why this is always a problem for me. Maybe I knit funny. I seem to have a bad eye for substitutions. And Gawd knows my math is bad.
Let's go from left to right, which is conveniently also from easiest to hardest:
Monkey socks, Hello Yarn. This one is less about gauge and more about, "Duh, always check Ravelry first!" I knit a couple of inches on 2.5 mm needles, as the pattern specifies (she calls these #2, in my book they're #1.5), before reluctantly acknowledging that they were coming out too big. Not impossibly big, but without any negative ease to make the pattern really pop. I looked up the pattern on Ravelry and sure enough, most people are using smaller needles. Forget social networking; this is the kind of thing that site is genius for--culling ideas, checking pattern bugs, seeing which designs actually look butt-ugly knit up, etc.
#1/2.25 mm probably would have been perfect, but one of my sets only has four needles and the other one is that obnoxious 8" size. Wait a mere 24 hours and buy another set? Noooo, couldn't do that. So I'm using #0/2 mm, and they take some careful squeezing over the instep. Maybe I'll decide to be all generous-like and give them to someone more petite of foot. Or maybe not.
Cobblestone sweater, Classic Elite Skye Tweed. Wow, I really felt like a paragon of virtue swatching for this one. It's the yarn the pattern calls for! But guess what: while my stitch gauge is dead on, my row gauge is 24 to his 29. Huh. I think I'm just going to plow ahead. Register your warnings now, so you can say "I told you so" with full righteousness when I fuck up the armscye.
Aran Pullover (Knitting for Baby), Louet Gems Topaz. OK, this one I'm going out on a limb for. The pattern calls for Russi Sales Easy Care 8 Ply, but I didn't expect I'd find that. I wanted something washable. I found a couple of things that were of comparable weight, but the colors sucked. S-U-C-K-E-D. You know, if someone came out with an affordable line of washable wool, geared towards baby things, in a decent palette with some depth, I bet they could make a mint (if you think such a product already exists, do tell!).
But the Louet, it was pretty, and washable, so I bought it. Pattern gauge is 17 stitches/28 rows in seed stitch on #8s; I'm getting 20/33. Upping the needles isn't an option, it's loose as it is. I might even need to use #7s. So my current plan is to [covers eyes with fingers] just knit a size bigger than I want. Oh c'mon, it's a baby sweater, it's not like there's really shaping involved!
What? What??
Teamkaty: Come for the complaining, stay for the inevitable trainwreck.
* I deserve a cupcake, don't you think? Maybe two? Please, I need positive reinforcement on this swatching business.